So far they are comfortable. Have yet to wear them in pouring rain and the size is a little larger but that is okay in case I want to use double layer or even thicker socks,Update March 2018The boots are roomy and now that I've had the chance to use them in rain...I have found there is a slight leak. My socks were a bit damp. I was disappointed. Not sure what the warranty is. It doesn't rain hard in Los Angeles, but, it is nice to have them when it does as it can get flooded. Hopefully, the leak doesn't worsen.These boots seem a little narrow but I think it really is just because they are rubber, so they don't have a lot of "give" - I am hoping they will feel a little better after a few wears to break them in. The calf portion seems tight, I have never had an issue with my calves being too large for boots so I think it is just the way these are made. I wouldn't be able to tuck my jeans into them, but can pull them over my leggings with no trouble. I got a lot of compliments wearing these out yesterday.After reading the other reviews I purchased one size larger than I normally wear. This allows for thicker socks to be worn with the rain boot. I purposely went out in the pouring down rain to see if they were waterproof as they said; splashed in some puddles with my granddaughter and the boot is what it says it is. My feet were completely dry.Really cute rain boots. Too bad it rarely rains in Southern California! I like that it has drawstrings at the top to keep water out. It's April; still waiting for the torrential el nino rains.I love these boots! I have the burgundy color & it's great. They fit my needs of walking in damp or rainy weather& keeping my feet dry. They are warm enough to wear to the pumpkin patch in the fall. Great for light mud. I like that they are a bit of a hybrid between winter boots and rainboots. And they are comfortable!They didn't keep my feet warm and the inside smell reminded me of kitty litter lolBoots are great but they do run a little large. The suggestion was going a size up for half sizes when it probably should've been a size down.These boots are made small. I had trouble squeezing my feet into them, they were too narrow. It seems one will have to buy two sizes up. I returned these boots.Ich trage Einlagen und muss immer etwas Größer wählen als meine Schuhgröße diesmal etwas zu groß geschätzt und hatte keine Lust zurück zuschicken. Ansonsten Kamik wie immer gute Qualität, komfortabel und super für alle Wetterlagen!一般的に大きく重い印象の冬のブーツですがすっきりした形でスマートですかかとがきつい印象ですが履いてしまうと動きやすい印象です少し足の茶色の箇所が硬く歩きにくさがあり、脱ぎぎもしにくいです。いつも25で26を買いちょうど良かったです。